

About John & Maria's Pizzeria-Restaurant
At John & Maria's Pizzeria-Restaurant, warmth meets culinary passion, creating an inviting space for pizza lovers. The attentive service, led by the friendly staff, has garnered praise from both locals and visitors, contributing to the pizzeria's beloved status. Guests appreciate the family-friendly atmosphere, making it a great spot for gathering with loved ones over delicious food. The menu features hand-tossed pizzas, like the beloved sausage and pepperoni, crafted with care. Seasonal specialties and house-made dishes add variety while retaining comfort food roots. Overall, John & Maria's blends swift service with consistent quality, ensuring a satisfying dining experience.
Location & Contact
- Address280 Foxon Rd, East Haven, CT 06513
- Websitehttps://johnandmariaspizza.com
- Phone(203) 466-1550
- Links Order online Β· Get directions
What to Expect
John & Maria's menu shines with New Haven-style pies and hearty Italian favorites. People rave about the thin crust pizzas, especially the sausage and cheese blends, perfectly balanced with sauce and toppings. Equally noteworthy are the Chicken Parm grinder and baked ziti, delightful for their generous portions and rich flavors. Desserts like Nutella cannoli and tiramisu receive high praise, adding sweetness to the meal. Overall, every dish is made with love, creating warm memories with each bite.
Hashtag Pizza Fact's
The Emotional Connection to Pizza
Pizza evokes strong emotional connections, often linked to nostalgia and comfort. Many people associate pizza with childhood memories, family gatherings, and social celebrations, making it a beloved staple in their lives. This emotional bond contributes to pizza's enduring popularity and its reputation as a universal comfort food that brings people together.
Menu Highlights
From the Community
John & Maria's Pizzeria-Restaurant has become a cherished destination in East Haven, with its reputation bolstered by glowing reviews. Customers frequently highlight the traditional thin crust pizza, which one reviewer affectionately described as "the best pizza in the world" praising its ideal blend of sauce and cheese. Visitors from nearby towns appreciate the laid-back atmosphere and inviting service, stating they feel like family with each visit. Deborah Bartlett notes, "The sauce really makes it great. I refuse to eat pizza anywhere else." This sentiment echoes throughout the reviews, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to quality and consistent flavors. The pizzeria has crafted a menu that satisfies diverse palates, from meatball subs brimming with flavor to the acclaimed eggplant parmigiana, adored by many. The personal touch, with owners John and Maria often present, leaves patrons feeling welcomed. Customers return frequently, making this establishment a staple in East Haven's vibrant dining scene. Whether you're seeking pizza or simply a place to unwind, John & Maria's offers a warm environment centered around delicious food, connecting the community through shared meals and lasting memories.
Why Locals Love It
Customer Reviews
"Well folks, let me tell ya, John and Mariaβs pie came out just about exactly as Dave Portnoy called itβand Iβll second that score right here. One bite, you know the rules, and the numberβs spot on. The cheese pie had that classic, no-nonsense New England thin crustβlittle char on the edge, sauce tucked under a healthy melt of cheese, not too greasy, not too fancy. Half pepperoni brought a bit of bite, cups curled up just enough to trap a little oil for flavor. Nothing over the top, but everything balanced, cooked right through, and consistent. Itβs the kind of pizza you respect because it doesnβt try too hard. They know what theyβre doing, theyβve been at it, and it lands right in that honest, dependable neighborhood spot zone. My score? Same as Portnoyβsβdead on the money."




"My Dad requested we all get together here after his funeral and so that we did. This was only my second time here as I live out of town but both the food and the service are top notch. Owners are the nicest people you could meet. I have got to get back here for the pizza which I know my Dad loved."




"Words can barely express how delicious the food is here, but Iβll try. Staff and owners are super nice, like a small family. They have the BEST FOOD, itβs all made by hand, they make their own sausage, anything with the sausage in it is amazing. Best stuffed mushrooms I have ever had hands down, best pizza, everything I have ever ordered has been super delicious. Itβs owned by a brother and sister, John and Maria, the first time I came in, they walked me through the hole menu, and when they handed me my food, I got it to go, they said, β this is a meal made with loveβ and you can tell. π I will absolutely be coming back here if Iβm ever back in town. I was in town building a local dispensary, here for about 2 months and ate here about 3-4 times a week for dinner, couldnβt get enuff! Well done John And Maria! I travel all over America for work, and you have been one of the top places I have ever been too!"




"This is THE BEST pizza in the world! We travel from Milford to pick up this awesome pizza. The sauce really makes it great. The toppings are the right proportion. The crust is hand tossed, and you can see that. Their eggplant topping is not to be missed. I refuse to eat pizza anywhere else. Give it a try!!!"




Hashtag Pizza Fact's
Pizza's Role in Social Gatherings
Pizza is a go-to choice for social gatherings due to its shareable nature and wide appeal. Whether for a casual movie night, a birthday party, or a business meeting, pizza easily accommodates diverse tastes and dietary preferences. Its versatility and convenience make it a staple at events, fostering a sense of community and enjoyment among attendees.
Connecticut's Premier Pizza Destinations
Current location in red, 8 nearest in blue, all others in gray
John & Maria's Pizzeria-Restaurant
Explore Nearby Restaurants
Click any restaurant to view details

Bobby's Apizza Restaurant
North Branford
2.7 miles away

Ozzy's Apizza
New Haven
3.7 miles away

One6Three
New Haven
3.9 miles away

Atticus Market
New Haven
4.0 miles away

Modern Apizza
New Haven
4.1 miles away

Da Legna at Nolo
New Haven
4.4 miles away

Zeneli Pizzeria e Cucina Napoletana
New Haven
4.5 miles away

Sally's Apizza
New Haven
4.7 miles away