Discover the best pizza restaurants in New Haven County
New Haven County stands at the heart of Connecticut’s pizza culture, renowned for its signature thin-crust, charred-edge apizza. The area’s historic ties to this style make it a must-stop on any Connecticut Pizza Trail adventure.
Ad Placeholder
Colony Grill in Norwalk serves razor-thin, crispy pizzas with a cult-following for its signature hot oil and stinger peppers. Expect casual bar vibes, outdoor seating, and a menu focused on build-your-own toppings and inventive salad pizzas.
A neighborhood New Haven pizza spot serving wood-fired, thin New Haven–style pies, inventive toppings and hearty sandwiches. Crowd favorites include Margherita, Buffalo Chicken, unique specials like Sweet & Salami, and a well-liked gluten-free crust option.
Wood-fired Neapolitan and thin-crust pies with house-made mozzarella and San Marzano tomato sauce, plus fresh pastas and Nutella dessert pizza. Family-run, speedy service and intimate indoor/outdoor seating make it a local favorite.
Neighborhood takeout known for New Haven–style pies: thin, crisp crusts, tangy tomato sauce and high-quality cheese. Specialty pies like mashed potato, clams casino and chipotle chicken stand alongside classic pepperoni and hearty Italian dinners via a quick takeout window.
Bright neighborhood deli and market in New Haven offering bakery-forward sandwiches, seasonal pastries, and a sourdough-driven pizza program. Coffee, outdoor seating, and curated pantry finds make it a go-to for quick lunches and leisurely afternoons.
BAR on Crown Street serves cracker-thin, charred New Haven–style pies alongside house-brewed beers and seasonal cocktails. Crowd-pleasing nontraditional pies like mashed potato & bacon and lobster roll stand out in a lively, music-forward atmosphere.
Along the shoreline, you’ll find pizzerias offering waterfront views and inventive toppings, with white clam pies and coal-fired ovens reflecting the region’s culinary roots. These seaside spots are perfect for both locals and visitors seeking a taste of tradition.
Ad Placeholder
Classic North Branford apizza joint known for a fresh thin crust, tangy tomato sauce and well-topped pies. Regulars rave about the Idahoan mashed‑potato pie, hearty grinders and a reliable, old‑school vibe served by friendly staff.
Bufalina in Guilford turns humble dough into bright, wood-fired Neapolitan pies with a thin, charred crust, seasonal toppings and simple salads. A tiny counter and garden patio set the scene for carefully chosen wines and cocktail pairings.
Christo’s turns out celebrated New Haven and Detroit styles with a well-done charred crust, bright tomato sauce, and generous toppings. The cozy bar and family-friendly dining pair pizzas with cocktails, salads, grinders and approachable comfort plates.
Bar-style, wafer-thin pizzas baked with a signature hot oil and simple toppings. Locals praise the Stingers and Salad pies, fast friendly service, a lively bar vibe, and outdoor seating that keeps downtown energy flowing.
Wood‑fired pizzas with a lightly charred, sourdough-tinged crust, inventive toppings like the Honeypot, and a big beer-and-cocktail program. Spacious, modern room with booths, a patio and consistent service praised by regulars and visitors alike.
Domenic's & Vinnie's serves thin, well-done pies with a savory tomato sauce and generous mozzarella. Known for large, square-cut pies and creative toppings like mashed potato and buffalo chicken, this cozy Middlebury spot consistently draws local fans.
Inland towns throughout the county bring their own flair, with Greek pan pizza and family-friendly restaurants offering hearty slices in welcoming settings. Parking is generally easy, making these spots accessible for a casual meal or group outing.
Ad Placeholder
Classic neighborhood pizzeria known for large, honestly topped pies and a mix of thin tavern-style and chewy old‑world crusts. Loyal diners applaud balanced, mildly seasoned sauce, high-quality cheese and generous sausage and pepperoni portions in a family-friendly setting.
A family-run, old-school pizza joint in Waterbury known for large, thin New York–style slices, a crisp yet chewy crust, straightforward tomato sauce and generous cheese. Popular with locals for garlic knots, grinders and wallet-friendly pies.
A family-run New Haven pizzeria known for a thin, crisp crust, generous cheese and savory toppings like meatball, broccoli rabe and fresh garlic. Friendly, steady service and a straightforward menu make it a reliable neighborhood favorite.
Est Est Est serves late-night New Haven–style pies with a crisp, airy yet charred crust, rich sauce and melting cheese. Casual, cozy spot known for slices, wings, hearty salads and house desserts that keep locals and students coming back.
Coal-fired, New Haven–style apizza in Cheshire known for thin, charred crusts, bright tomato sauce and a savory pecorino finish. Counter service and limited seating keep pies moving; reviewers highlight the margherita, Fuoco Special and burrata.
A cozy, wood-fired pizzeria in Milford known for New Haven–style crusts, bright red sauce, and generous homemade pastas. Locals praise fresh ingredients, memorable desserts, and a friendly bar-to-table vibe that works for families and solo diners alike.
College towns in New Haven County add a lively, late-night energy to the pizza scene. Slices are often available into the early hours, catering to students, night owls, and anyone craving a midnight bite.
Ad Placeholder
A long-running Shoreline pizza spot known for thin, New Haven–style pies with a crisp, slightly charred crust, bright tomato sauce, and generous cheese. Friendly, busy rooms and a bar make it a reliable pick for pizza lovers in Madison.
Wood‑fired, thin‑crust pies and classic Italian plates in a cozy Prospect spot. Expect crisp Margheritas, garlic knots, wings and a compact menu tuned for bright, fresh flavors and friendly, attentive service.
Family-run pizzeria in Wallingford known for very thin, crisp crusts, generous grinders and classic Italian plates. Reviewers praise fresh toppings, hearty portions, friendly service, outdoor seating and a full bar with cocktails and beer.
Jam City Pizza turns Detroit-style pies into inventive, crispy squares served from a cellar kitchen in Hamden. Locally praised for bold sauces, generous deep slices and truffle-forward toppings, it’s a casual spot for hearty, shareable pizza.
A Milford take on New Haven apizza, known for a slightly charred, crispy outer crust and a flavorful tomato sauce. The menu balances classic pies with playful options like pickle and garbage pizza, plus dependable sides and friendly service.
This charming pizzeria offers a delightful selection of classic pizzas and Italian dishes, renowned for its homemade flavors and welcoming atmosphere in East Haven.
Many pizzerias in the area thoughtfully provide gluten-free and vegetarian options, ensuring everyone can enjoy a slice. This commitment to dietary inclusivity is just one more reason New Haven County stands out on the Connecticut Pizza Trail.
Ad Placeholder
Julio's Wood Fired Pizza & Grill offers a delightful dining experience with a focus on wood-fired pizzas and Italian dishes. Known for friendly service and cozy atmosphere, it's a popular choice for both dine-in and takeout.
The Little Rendezvous is a beloved pizza joint in Meriden, CT, known for its excellent coal-fired pizzas, welcoming atmosphere, and dedicated service.
Known for its crispy crust and generous toppings, Mike's Apizza & Restaurant serves classic New Haven-style pizzas and comforting dishes in a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere.
Famed for its New Haven-style pies, Modern Apizza delivers a memorable experience with well-balanced flavors, an energetic atmosphere, and time-honored pizza perfection. Perfect for dining in or takeout.
A treasured local spot, Napoli Pizza Restaurant serves exquisite Italian dishes, specializing in pizza that delights the palate. Dine in a cozy atmosphere that emphasizes family-friendly service.
New Haven Pizza Place serves classic New Haven-style pizza with a focus on quality ingredients and delicious flavors, creating a cozy atmosphere perfect for families and friends.
Brewery taprooms and casual bars across the county serve up classic tavern pies alongside local craft beers. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick lunch or a relaxed evening, there’s always a welcoming spot to enjoy pizza in New Haven County.
Ad Placeholder
Olde World Apizza serves up delicious, New Haven-style pies known for their charred crust and fresh toppings, making it a cherished local favorite in North Haven.
Ozzy's Apizza brings an authentic taste of New Haven-style pizza with its thin, charred crust, fresh toppings, and welcoming atmosphere. Their unique pies are a hit among locals.
Renowned for its New Haven style pizza, Papa's Pizza in Milford offers a comforting dining experience with a focus on quality toppings and exceptional service. A local favorite for takeout and fans of classic American pizza.
A beloved neighborhood pizza spot known for delicious pies, fast service, and a welcoming atmosphere, perfect for family dinners or quick takeout.
Roma Pizzeria offers a delightful array of New Haven style pizzas, complemented by a cozy atmosphere and friendly service. Their brick oven pizza is a highlight, making it a cherished spot for locals.
Known for its authentic New Haven-style pizza, Roseland Apizza combines flavor and charm in a cozy setting, attracting both locals and visitors alike for its exceptional food and welcoming atmosphere.
Rossini's serves delightful Italian fare with an inviting atmosphere, featuring outstanding pizza and pasta dishes. Known for personalized service, this family-run spot has quickly become a local favorite.
Sally's Apizza serves exceptional coal-fired pizzas in a vibrant atmosphere, renowned for its rich flavors and unique menu offerings like the clam pie and cannoli pie.
Tipsy Tomato offers a delightful pizza experience with a variety of specialty pies, including indulgent stuffed shrimp pizza. The cozy atmosphere and attentive service make it a local favorite for casual dining.
Zois Pizza Palace welcomes locals with its friendly atmosphere and exceptional Greek-style pizzas. Renowned for their crispy crust and delicious toppings, it's a favorite for both casual dining and takeout.
In West Haven, Zuppardi's Apizza serves delicious New Haven-style pizza, renowned for its flavorful toppings, crispy crust, and welcoming atmosphere. A local favorite, it balances tradition with quality and community spirit.